With Google Page Creator being eliminated, I have decided to do a quick comparison of Google Page Creator (GPC) and Google Sites. I have put this together to aid in making a decision on where to migrate my Google Page Creator site to.
This comparison is not exhaustive, but centered around the key features of GPC
Feature Comparison | ||
Branding | ||
Item | Google Page Creator | Google Sites |
Domain Name Integration | Your domain name was used as the root for all pages | Your Domain Name redirects to http://sites.google.com/a/domain by default, but you can map individual Google Sites to different DNS names (i.e. www.yourdomain.com can map to a specific site. This is new, and available for Google Apps for Domain users |
FavIcon | You can brand your site with a FavIcon using simple Javascript | No support for FavIcon (except Googles icon) |
Themes | Each page could have a different theme and with CSS you had pretty fine control over presentation of the site. | Themes apply to the whole site. You can modify additional properties of the theme like colors and fonts and some background images. |
Technology | ||
Item | Google Page Creator | Google Sites |
Javascript | Javascript is allowed on pages. | Javascript is NOT allowed on pages |
CSS | You can integration custom CSS files using Javascript to direct the client to load the file. | You cannot integrate custom CSS Files |
Google Analytics | You can add Analytics via javascript. You have control over how each page is tracked. | You can track whole site with form entry for Analytics Account |
Google Adsense | You can add Adsense ad blocks via javascript | Adsense not supported |
Google Gadgets | Supported | Supported, but not ones that run Javascript on the client |
Google Webmasters Tools | Supported via uploaded file. | Supported via a form to add the Meta Tag. |
Other Webmasters Tools | Supported via uploaded files. | Not supported. You can add their meta tag, but Google replaces the name with Google's. |
Static Files | Can upload files via HTTP to root directory. Cannot make sub directories. | Can upload via HTTP into a file cabinet. Site visitors can see if the file cabinet is visible. |
Limits | Maximum Files = 500 Maximum Space = 100 MB Maximum File Size = 10 MB Themes = 41 | Maximum Space = 100 MB for non Domain account and 10GB for Google Apps for Domains account Maximum File Size = 10 MB Themes = 23 |
Google Docs Integration | Integration via Google Gadgets | Good built-in integration via editor |
Editor | ||
Item | Google Page Creator | Google Sites |
Tables | You can create tables manually with HTML code | Editor includes built in table editor. |
Page Layout | Supports 5 Page Layouts | Supports 2 Layouts (with Permanent Side Bar which can be moved left or right - (This makes 4 total layouts)) |
Navigation | Create your own navigation and breadcrumbs and sitemaps. | Automatically creates navigation, breadcrumbs and sitemaps. |
Comments | Cannot incorporate comments from visitors | Can incorporate comments from visitors |
Summary
Google Sites seems to be a fair replacement for Google Page Creator with a few exceptions.
- Branding: If Favicons and tweeks to site presentation using CSS are required
- Javascript: If there is functionality that requires Javascript
- Adsense: If you want to monetize your site.
Related Posts:
GPC to Office Live Comparision
GPC to Weebly Comparision
Review my Delicious Links related to this Post at http://delicious.com/tim.alosi/gpc
1 comment:
I am looking for the instructions to google pages or google sites or blogger.Any help finding them would be appreciated.
edward.halloran@yahoo.com
Post a Comment